In 2026, two 20-foot-wide townhouses on East 64th Street sold a few avenue blocks apart. The larger one went for $4 million less than the smaller one.
The first was 10 East 64th Street, between Fifth and Madison. It was built in 1879, has 8,725 square feet, and sold for $14 million after almost four years on the market. Its first ask in 2022 was $26.5 million. The second was 165 East 64th Street, between Lexington and Third. It asked $18.5 million and closed on July 24, 2026, at $18 million. The second house has less space and sold for more because its renovation was finished. This year's Lenox Hill sales show the same split again and again. A finished house trades close to its ask. A house that still needs its renovation trades at a price that leaves the buyer room to pay for that work and to wait for it.
Two houses on East 64th Street
As 6sqft reported, Ivana Trump bought No. 10 for roughly $2.5 million in 1992. Designer George Gregorian redid it in a maximalist style, with gold accents, upholstered walls and a library covered in leopard print. In the same article, 6sqft explained the long wait for a buyer with a 2023 comment from fashion designer Dennis Basso: "nobody with this kind of money wants a 30-year-old bathroom." The $14 million price works out to about $1,605 per square foot. At that price, the buyer is paying for a house that they will renovate anyway.
No. 165 took a different route. The New York Post reported that developer Titanium Property Group bought it for $6.5 million in 2024 and gutted it, including the facade, which went from brownstone to limestone. The developer also added a fifth floor, an elevator, a roof deck with a summer kitchen, a home gym and radiant floors inside and out. According to the Post, an international financier agreed to pay close to the ask, all in cash, within three weeks of the listing. "People don't want old townhouses," the listing broker told the paper.
Titanium's 2024 purchase price and the 2026 sale price are $11.5 million apart. The buyer paid that difference for a house whose renovation was already done.
What the discount on East 70th Street paid for
34-36 East 70th Street was the clearest test this year of what an unfinished house is worth. It is a gutted two-house assemblage, and it came with plans approved by the Landmarks Preservation Commission to turn it into a five-story, 12,500-square-foot single-family house with eight bedrooms, seven bathrooms, a back garden and two terraces. According to The Real Deal, it last traded for $18.3 million in 2018, came on the market in March 2024 at $36 million, and went on and off the market with several brokerages before it went into contract at a $24.5 million ask in the week ending May 3, 2026.
Property records compiled by Traded show that the sale closed on August 24, 2026, at $20.72 million, or $1,657 per square foot of the planned house. Traded files the deal as a development site. The final price was about 42% below the first ask and about 15% below the contract ask. It was about $2.4 million above the 2018 price, eight years later.
The per-square-foot numbers are worth comparing. Per foot, a gutted shell with approved plans sold for about what No. 10 East 64th fetched, even though No. 10 is a furnished, livable house with a 30-year-old interior. Buyers priced both as projects. Approved plans matter, but in this sale they did not close the gap to a finished house.
Another house on the same street shows how long finishing can take. In 2009, John and Christy Mack bought 165 East 70th Street, a 33-foot-wide former garage, for $13.5 million. Their gut renovation took six years. They kept the landmarked limestone facade, added a floor, reinforced the structure with steel, and ended up with a house of about 16,000 square feet and 20 rooms. Their listing broker told the New York Post that the couple had looked for a move-in-ready townhouse for about ten years before they decided to build their own. Counting the search and the renovation, they spent about sixteen years getting a finished house. The LLC that closed on 34-36 East 70th Street in August bought a gutted structure and a set of approved plans, which puts it near the start of the same process.
The finished house has a ceiling, too
At the top of the market, sellers are pricing a finished renovation aggressively. The Macks listed 165 East 70th Street in October at $80 million. Appraiser Jonathan Miller told the Post that a sale at that price would beat Manhattan's townhouse record of $77.1 million, set in June 2019 by 14 East 67th Street. Two blocks west, 5 East 63rd Street sold for $15.5 million in August 2022. After a renovation that added a hammam, a sauna, a fitness center and an elevator, it came back on the market this August at $52 million.
The Real Deal wrote that the East 63rd Street house could still sell for less than its ask. It pointed to a West Village mansion at 105-107 Bank Street that asked $75 million and sold for $70 million, and to an Upper West Side townhouse that set a neighborhood record while closing 50% below its first asking price. A finished house sells close to its ask when the ask is realistic. No. 165 East 64th asked $18.5 million and got $18 million.
Short supply is what keeps these prices firm. Citing a quarterly townhouse report, The Real Deal said the average Upper East Side townhouse sold for just under $14 million in the second quarter of 2026, up more than 49% from a year earlier, on 32 sales compared with 36 a year before. It added that Manhattan townhouse inventory in that quarter was more than 20% below its ten-year average, according to Miller's report. In his third-quarter 2026 Housing Notes, Miller reported that the average Manhattan townhouse sold in the quarter measured 4,552 square feet, down 7.9% from a year earlier, which pulled the average price figures lower. He also wrote that almost no new townhouses are being built because "buyers demand authentic turn-of-the-century structures even if the homes have been gutted to the party walls."
That last point explains the Lenox Hill market. Buyers want an old house with new insides, and very few of those come up for sale. The houses that need work are the raw material for the next finished house.
The 2026 ledger
| Address | Condition when offered | First ask | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 East 64th Street | Livable, with a 30-year-old decorative interior | $26.5 million, 2022 | Sold for $14 million, reported March 2026 |
| 165 East 64th Street | Gut-renovated, new limestone facade, added fifth floor | $18.5 million, 2026 | Closed at $18 million, July 24, 2026 |
| 34-36 East 70th Street | Gutted shell with approved plans | $36 million, March 2024 | Closed at $20.72 million, August 24, 2026 |
| 5 East 63rd Street | Renovated after a 2022 purchase | $52 million, August 2026 | Listed |
| 165 East 70th Street | Six-year conversion of a former garage | $80 million, October 2026 | Listed |
| 167 East 74th Street | Two-family house, one owner since 1966 | $9.8 million, April 2026 | Relisted at $8.995 million, October 2026 |
The house in the middle on East 74th Street
167 East 74th Street, known on the block as the Squirrel House for the bronze squirrels at its entrance, sits between the finished houses and the shells. According to 6sqft, it was built in 1910, expanded in 1956, and was home to art collector and longtime MoMA trustee Barbara Jakobson from 1966 on. It is 20 feet wide and about 6,000 square feet, set up as a two-family house that includes a two-bedroom duplex off the entrance. The garden level has a sunken living room with 19-foot ceilings that opens onto a 350-square-foot garden, and the parlor-floor entry hall is papered in a custom design by Peter Halley. It first came on the market in April at $9.8 million and was relisted in October at $8.995 million, about 8% lower.
At the current ask, that is roughly $1,500 per square foot. That is close to what buyers paid this year for the East 70th Street shell and for No. 10 East 64th, and well below what a finished, new-build-quality house got on East 64th. The market is treating this house as a project. If you would keep much of its design history, you can pay a project price for a house you would mostly live in as it is. Someone who wants a result like 165 East 64th has to add the cost of the renovation and the years it takes to the purchase price, and the 2026 sales suggest comparing that total with what a finished house sells for, not with this house's asking price.
The same pattern holds across the river. This August a gut-renovated house at 40 Garden Place in Brooklyn Heights traded for $11.5 million, more than twice its 2022 price. For buyers comparing the Upper East Side with other townhouse neighborhoods, the useful comparison is between houses in the same condition. Lenox Hill's medians mix finished houses and project houses, and the two trade on different terms.
Whether you are weighing a finished house on a Lenox Hill side street against one that still needs its renovation, or deciding whether to renovate before you sell, The Bracha Group can help you price both the house and the years of work it needs. Start with our Lenox Hill team, or ask for a confidential valuation of your own house. Work With Us.